An appellate court says a federal judge in Nashville gave short shrift to media organizations’ bid to block a state law that creates a 25-foot “buffer zone” around police and makes it a crime to refuse to move outside it.
The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is striking down a decision by U.S. District Judge William L. Campbell Jr., in which Campbell denied media organizations’ request to block enforcement of the law pending a challenge to its constitutionality.
In its ruling, the three-judge panel said Campbell did not address a key consideration for granting the injunction — the media outlets’ likelihood of success in challenging the buffer-zone law as unconstitutional.
The court said such a consideration is “the most important one in First Amendment cases,” but Campbell didn’t address it at all.
“The district court must create an adequate factual record on these and any other relevant issues for that court or ours to apply the applicable standard for injunctive relief,” the 6th Circuit opinion stated.
Citizens, journalists subject to arrest
The Tennessee Legislature enacted a law last year that created a 25-foot “buffer zone” around police officers carrying out their official duties — essentially blocking citizens and journalists from observing law enforcement in public settings.
It also made a violation of the law a misdemeanor crime for which citizens and journalists could be arrested, prosecuted and, if convicted, jailed for six months.
Media organizations including the Tennessee Lookout, Nashville Banner, Nexstar Media Group, Scripps Media Inc., Gannett Co. Inc., Nashville Public Media and Tegna Inc. filed the federal lawsuit challenging the buffer-zone law last July after it took effect.
The law applies to all citizens, not just journalists, and is widely seen as an effort to keep citizens and journalists from documenting police action. It allows officers to order citizens to stay back 25 feet even if there is no risk to the safety of the officer or the public.
Media organizations in their lawsuit argued the law violates the First Amendment and is unconstitutionally vague. They sought an injunction to bar the state from enforcing the law pending resolution of the lawsuit.
Law ‘has grave implications’ for news gatherers
Attorney Paul McAdoo of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press is serving as lead counsel for the various media organizations. In the lawsuit, McAdoo set out the reasoning behind the media challenge to the buffer-zone law.
“The Act has grave implications for the ability of reporters and news organizations … to exercise their First Amendment rights,” McAdoo wrote.
“The Act grants officers standardless discretion to prevent journalists from approaching near enough to document the way officers perform their duties in public places,” he wrote. “In other words, it provides for government by the moment-to-moment opinions of a policeman on his beat.”
McAdoo said the act hinders journalists from doing their jobs and subjects them to arrest for doing their jobs.
“The Act authorizes law enforcement officers to bar journalists (and the public) from reporting — for any reason or no reason — on a wide range of events of public interest, including a parade, a rally, an arrest, or an accident scene,” McAdoo wrote.
“The Act applies with equal force to a reporter gathering the news in a park, standing on a sidewalk, or lawfully present in other spaces open to the public,” he continued. “And the Act provides no exceptions for circumstances where 25 feet is too far — as it will often be too far — for the press or public to document newsworthy activity, including officers’ own performance of their official responsibilities.”
Jamie Satterfield is an investigative journalist covering crime, courts and the stories behind the headlines. She writes Let’s Talk: Law for KnoxTNToday, digging deeper to uncover the story behind the story.
Read more of Jamie Satterfield’s columns and learn more about her in her author bio on her KnoxTNToday author page. Follow her investigative reporting on Substack.
Take a puzzle break! Play WordRow, Sudoku or Crosswords today! Choose your favorite puzzle in the site navigation.
Follow KnoxTNToday on Facebook, Instagram, X, LinkedIn, and TikTok. Get all KnoxTNToday articles in one place with our free newsletter. Comments may be sent to news@knoxtntoday.com.